IHTSDO-767 (artf235830) Military findings
IHTSDO Content development – fast track (simple/single changes)
Word version documents located at the bottom of this page.
Review of Classification of Some Military Service Findings
(artf235830 – 'Move History relating to military service from findings to situations')
Version Information
Document Author(s): | Sarah Harry |
Change Owner: |
|
Content Editor: | tbc |
Version: | 0.3 |
Date Created: | 20170103 |
Document status | Draft |
Related Tracker Artifact(s): |
Document review
Reviewer | Review date | Comment |
Jim Case/Jim Campbell |
| V0.1 First draft for review |
|
| V0.2 Document revised to clarify structure of argument and address points made by reviewers regarding criteria for context definition. Note: No change to conclusions. SH |
| 20170103 | V0.3 Section on 'Solution Proposed' made more explicit regarding need to await elaboration of guidance on past context. |
Table of Contents
- 1 Statement of problem as requested or initially identified
- 2 Relevance to International edition
- 3 Related changes impacted by this content development request
- 4 Agreed scope statement
- 5 Problem: "The concept 365549006 – 'Finding of history relating to military service (finding)' is misplaced."
- 6 Problem: "Some of the children are also history concepts."
- 7 Identification of additional changes
- 8 Solutions proposed
- 9 Stakeholder input
- 10 Impact assessment
- 11 Risk assessment
- 12 Approval process
- 13 Priority
- 14 Content editing
- 15 Details of content changes
- 16 Manual quality check
- 17 Automated quality check
- 18 Publish to release branch
Statement of problem as requested or initially identified
IHTSDO Content Tracker Description:
"The concept 365549006 – 'Finding of history relating to military service (finding)' is misplaced and some of the children are also history concepts. These need to be moved to the situation hierarchy."
Tracker details at date 20160613:
https://csfe.aceworkspace.net/sf/go/artf235830 |
Relevance to International edition
Consideration of the issue falls within scope of the international edition. The content describing military service findings uses a nomenclature in common use world-wide and is consistently understood. There are no obvious country-specific references.
Related changes impacted by this content development request
No related changes are identified as the proposal and solution are tightly constrained within a limited sub-hierarchy.
Agreed scope statement
This is limited to the small subhierarchy '365549006 | Finding of history relating to military service (finding)>>'. This has 16 subtypes:
365549006 | Finding of history relating to military service (finding)
266963001 | Exempt from military service (finding)
276088008 | Conscientious objector (finding)
276090009 | Medically unfit for service (finding)
276089000 | Non-combatant (finding)
10987541000119104 | History of military deployment (finding)
236305007 | Joined military forces (finding)
266964007 | Left military service (finding)
276085006 | Bought out of service (finding)
276087003 | Deserted from military service (finding)
276086007 | Dishonourable discharge (finding)
276083004 | Failed service training (finding)
276082009 | Medical discharge from forces (finding)
276084005 | Resigned commission (finding)
224355006 | Served in armed forces (finding)
419482003 | Served in armed forces in combat (finding)
224357003 | Served in peace time (finding)
The issue is specifically those concepts describing patient 'history' but can be taken to be seeking a review of all findings here that describe a past event. Speculatively, users may have problems where they cannot locate all 'History of clinical finding' concepts grouped in the situations hierarchy. The issues can be split out:
Copyright © 2025, SNOMED International