2021-02-24 Editorial Advisory Group Conference call

2021-02-24 Editorial Advisory Group Conference call

 

Date: 2021-02-24

Time:

1830- 2000 UTC

1030-1200 PDT

Zoom Meeting Details

Hi there,

Jim Case is inviting you to a scheduled SNOMED International Zoom meeting.

Topic: SNOMED Editorial Advisory Group Conference Call
Time: This is a recurring meeting Meet anytime

Join from PC, Mac, Linux, iOS or Android:
https://snomed.zoom.us/j/99997961770?pwd=TWRiclpVeTU3RG1kUE1lTWNkVFBCZz09
Password: 287392

Meeting ID: 999 9796 1770

Password: 287392
International numbers available: https://snomed.zoom.us/u/abTbQn2e26

Or Skype for Business (Lync):
https://snomed.zoom.us/skype/99997961770

 

Attendees

Chair:

  • @Jim Case

AG Members

  • @Alejandro Lopez Osornio 

  • @Monique van Berkum

  • @Jim Campbell

  • @Jeffrey Pierson

  • @Jeremy Rogers

  • @Former user (Deleted)

  • @Former user (Deleted)

  • Invitees:

  • @Bruce Goldberg

Observers:

@Anne Randorff Højen

@Monica Harry

@John Snyder (Unlicensed)

@Nicholas McGraw

@Krista Lilly

@Yongsheng Gao

 

 

Apologies:

@Daniel Karlsson

 

Meeting Files:

Meeting minutes:

The call recording is located here.

 

Objectives

  • Obtain consensus on agenda items

Discussion items

Item

Description

Owner

Notes

Action

Item

Description

Owner

Notes

Action

1

Call to order and role call

@Jim Case

Start recording!

 

2

Conflicts of interest and agenda review

 

@Jim Case

No conflicts noted

 

 

3

FSN naming for "Pathologic neoplastic fractures"

@Jim Case

Search of the literature yielded very few references with a consensus naming for this type of fracture.  Search terms included:

  • "Neoplastic fracture"

  • "Neoplastic pathologic fracture"

  • "Metastatic fracture" 

As was agreed, these are not fractures DUE TO the neoplastic disease and have been modeled as co-occurrent. As there is no consensus naming for these, potential terming includes:

  • "Fracture of X with neoplastic disease"

  • "Fracture of X in neoplastic disease"

  • "Fracture of X co-occurrent with neoplastic disease"

  • "Neoplastic disease with pathologic fracture of X"

  • "Neoplastic fracture of X"

  • Other...

Discussion:

Consider "Fracture of X with neoplastic bone disease".  Is the neoplasm the cause of the weakened bone or is it possible that treatment or extranous condition resulted in the fracture? Prior uses implied that the neoplasm was in the bone.  Suggesed "Fracture of X with neoplasm of X ".  Treatments leading to osteoporosis could be classified under osteoporotic fractures.  Additional discussion  "Fracture of X at site of neoplasm" or "Pathologic fracture of X at site of neoplasm".

Decision:

Group consensus is to use "Pathologic fracture of X at site of neoplasm".

@Jim Case to implement decision on naming of Pathological fractures

4

Concept Inactivation update and proposals

@Former user (Deleted)

A presentation summarising the proposals detailed in the document 'Concept Inactivation - Proposed Amendments

A request for the members to review and feedback on the  document found on the Confluence web page: Concept Inactivation - Proposed Amendments

A short discussion on 'where do we go from here'

Discussion:

Presentation covered and EAG tasked with review of the document and comments for the next EAG Call.

@Former user (Deleted) to post slides to agenda and minutes
EAG members to review concets inactivaiton documentation and send comments to @Former user (Deleted)

5

Glascow coma score and assessment scale components

@Jim Case

@Former user (Deleted) @Jim Campbell

Based on a discussion at the Anesthesia CRG and Observables Project there is a requirement to add more content for Glasgow Coma Scale

Please see full discussion here: https://snomed.atlassian.net/wiki/display/ACRGT/Glasgow+Coma+Score

Presentation included with this agenda item suggesting common observables definitions.

References to Standarization of the GCS:

https://zibs.nl/wiki/GlasgowComaScale-v3.2(2020EN)

https://ckm.openehr.org/ckm/archetypes/1013.1.137/printable

https://www.glasgowcomascale.org/

Draft document from Anesthesia CRG: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1lZJlarREeIIRPk5E1zVtZUktLQlPH3G5/view?usp=sharing

Discussions within Observables Project Group and and review of assessment scores deployed at Nebraska have proceeded with extended proposal for inclusion of assessment scales in use in Sweden as well as US.   

Modelling proposal added to Attachment s summarizing Assessment Scale Score Observables development: Clinical Scale Scores_20210224.pptx.  Proposal promotes expanding content model for full definition of scales such as co-morbidity, Glasgow Coma Scale and SOFA scores.

Anesthesia CRG wishes to explore further the best model for including definitions/explanations of Ordinal Scale score Value sets used in calculated scores.

Discussion:

Ongoing discussions with anesthesia and Observables groups.  Scope expanded.  Continued to the nest meeting.

@Jim Campbell and @Former user (Deleted) to provide example of observables for assessment scales
EAG to review document for examples of findings that clinicians would like to see

6

ECE Topics

@Bruce Goldberg

  • Additional considerations for disorder association modeling

  • Updated model for contact dermatitis

Discussion: 

Suggested that the use of DUE TO be constrained to the immediate cause as opposed to the entire causal chain. Combined disorders would always be considered co-occurrent. 

Modeling of multiple CLINICAL COURSE:  For concepts where there are two clinical courses required, suggest adding the clinical course to each of the RGs representing the combined disorders.   Some issues are whether the existing terms actually represent a proper term, such as an acute disorder due to a recurrent disorder. (Presentation is always acute).

Including CLINICAL COURSE in the RG would require remodeling of many thousands of existing concepts. 

Question regarding adding the DUE TO relationship to RGs as well.  This requires additional discussion. 

Contact dermatitis discussion continued to next call in March 2021

Decision:

Combined disorders would be modeled as co-occurrent and a DUE TO relationship will be added for the immediate cause, if applicable.

@Krista Lilly to update the editorial guide to represent the combined disorder decision.

7

Evaluation to Observables (E2O project) update

@Daniel Karlsson@James Campbell

  • Proposal for transfer of concepts from <<Evaluation Procedures to Observable entities under going model development in Protege for Phase 1 (Lab testing procedures) in order to test hierarchy build and revisions.

 

8

Congenital aplasia modeling redux

@Jim Case

Issues observed with inferences based on the original proposal have arisen that require a revised modeling pattern.  Discussion located at: 

Re: Proposed remodeling of Congenital absence concepts - For discussion (revised)

EAG members to review changes and comment.

9

Next meeting

EAG

March 24, 2021

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Copyright © 2025, SNOMED International