MABH-CRG Meeting: 26 Feb 2025

MABH-CRG Meeting: 26 Feb 2025

26 Feb 2025

GoToMeeting Details

Attendees

@Piper Ranallo PhD 

@Ed Cheetham 

@Elaine Wooler 

@Jan Ivar Ernø 

@Irina Angel

@Laura Fochtmann

Apologies

@Former user (Deleted) 

@andrew williams

@Ian Green 

@Rebecca Berman 

Objectives

Discussion items

Item

Description

Owner

Notes

Action

Item

Description

Owner

Notes

Action

0

86110000 |Rumination - thoughts (finding)|

@Jan Ivar Ernø 

see link here: 

86110000 |Rumination - thoughts (finding)| mapping to F or R in ICD?

discussed, @Jan Ivar Ernø has resolution 

1

Affectivity

@Piper Ranallo PhD 

25467004 |Hyperaffectivity (finding)|

33314005 | Hypoaffectivity (finding) |

Clarify meaning and position in hierarchy.  

Definition of affectivity (APA Dictionary):

The degree of a person’s response or susceptibility to pleasure, pain, and other emotional stimuli. Evaluation of affectivity is an important component of a psychological examination; the therapist or clinician may look for evidence of such reactions as blunted affect, inappropriate affect, loss of affect, ambivalence, depersonalization, elation, depression, or anxiety.

https://dictionary.apa.org/affectivity

  • Note: this definition does not seem to explicitly distinguish between internal response and externally observable response.

  • Thus far, we have defined affect as the "observable expression of emotion" 

Consider

  • Inactivate Is a relationship: 106131003 |Mood finding (finding)|  

  • New is a relationship must refer to the expression of emotion without claim that emotion is or is not being expressed (i.e., lack of expression of emotion is affect) 

Discussion

  • Previously discussed looking at translations - who can do this??    

  • Previously discussed looking at clinical value of the concept? – see examples of assessments (SANS), as well as affect data captured in EHR  





After discussion, the consensus was to leave the 2 concepts as-is; the term "affect" in these concepts refers to mood or emotion (as in 'affective disorder") not to expression of emotion (as in 'abnormal affect')



Laura noted that the following concepts are mis-represented as subtypes of 'abnormal affect':

  • | Affective instability trait (finding) |   

  • | Hypomanic personality trait (finding) |

xssstwo 2

State and Disposition



@Ed Cheetham will lead a discussion about the problematic state concepts (mental state / emotional state) and provide historical context.

The goal is to use this information to inform next steps around high priority decision to create more general concepts for "mental state finding" and "emotional state finding"

 Decision / Next steps=













Meeting Files

  File Modified

PDF File SANS.pdf

2025-Feb-26 by Piper Ranallo PhD

Microsoft Word Document Affect findings.docx

2025-Feb-26 by Piper Ranallo PhD



Previous Meetings

TitleCreatorModified
No content found.



Copyright © 2025, SNOMED International